Archive for December 2013

ریاست اور ریاست کی رٹ !! بندا پوچھے

ریاست اور ریاست کی رٹ !! بندا پوچھے

تحریر : حدید شیر 

حد ہو گئی یعنی کے .. ریاست کی رٹ ہونی چاہیے کی رٹ سن سن کر کان پک گۓ ہیں ..کیا پنجاب کیا بلوچستان کیا سندھ اور کیا نیا خیبر پختونخواہ ..
بندا پوچھے
 جو حکومت رکشوں کے سلنسر میں ڈھولکی نہیں دلوا سکتی 
جو حکومت ایک تانگے والے کو گھوڑے کی لد سڑکوں پر کروانے سے نہیں روک سکتی 
جو حکومت ملک کے سب سے بڑے صوبے کی سب سے بڑی جامعہ میں بدمعاش طلبہ تنظیموں کے آگے جھک جاۓ 
جو حکومت ایک سبزی والے کومن پسند نرخوں پہ فروخت سے نہیں روک سکتی 
جو حکومت ریاستی افسروں کو دفتروں میں سگرٹ نوشی سے نہیں روک سکتی 
جو حکومت ایک پرچون فروش کو ملاوٹ سے نہیں روک سکتی 
 جو حکومت پبلک ٹرانسپورٹ میں اونچی آواز سے بجتے موسیقی کے طوفان بدتمیزی کے آگے بند باندھنے سے قاصر ہو 
جس حکومت کے ساڑھے تین لاکھ پولیس اہلکار چند سو پولیو ورکرز کی حفاظت نہیں کر سکتے 
جس حکومت کا ڈاکٹروں کی ہڑتال کے آگے دم گھٹا ہو 
جو حکومت اساتذہ کی سکول حاضری کو ممکن نہ بنا سکے 
جو حکومت ایک سیاسی جماعت کی طرف سے تجارتی نقل و حمل میں رکاوٹ کو ٹھنڈے پیٹوں برداشت کرنے پر مجبور ہو 
جو حکومت تیسرے درجے کے صحافیوں کی چادر اور چاردیواری کو پامال کرنے پر تماشا دیکھے 
جو حکومت اپنی پولیس کی نجی جیلوں کو بند نہ کروا سکے 
جو حکومت اسٹیج ڈراموں کے نام پر موجود گند کو صاف کرنے کی صلاحیت سے محروم ہو 
جو حکومت مزدوروں کو پوری تنخواہ نہ دلوا سکے
جو حکومت یوریا کھاد کی بلیک میں فروخت نہ رکوا سکے
جو حکومت سڑکوں پر بیٹھے عاملوں کے نام سے لفظ پروفیسر نہ ختم کروا سکے
جو حکومت پچھلے سو دنوں سے ایک پانچ سالہ بچی سے زیادتی کے مجرم نہ پکڑ سکی
جس حکومت کے وزیر اعلی کو تھانے جانے سے ڈر لگتا ہو 
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
اس حکومت سے ریاستی رٹ کی توقع ...
حد ہو گئی یعنی کے .. ریاست کی رٹ ہونی چاہیے کی رٹ سن سن کر کان پک گۓ ہیں ..کیا پنجاب کیا بلوچستان کیا سندھ اور کیا نیا خیبر پختونخواہ ..
بندا پوچھے


PNA movement 1977 and GE'13 "rigging" | Thinking outside the bun

PNA movement 1977 & GE'13 "rigging" |  Thinking outside the bun

Written by Engr. Hadeed Sher



Ever since the general elections 2013 there is an ongoing mantra of rigging by some fellow countrymen who are following the due course of Pakistani politics where one either loses or the elections are rigged. These people, equipped with the social media tools, are frenzied over the loss of their favorite candidate. However, since for most of them this has been there first ever democratic experience therefore they deny the existence of basic right of democracy. The holiest of the holy "Every citizen has equal status". Thus the person living in slums has a value of vote that is equal to the vote of a person living in President house. The election rigging has now turned into a carol where a single party is trying to sample the election in 1000 constituencies of Pakistan through 4 selected constituencies of their own choice. This party calls itself Pakistan ehreek Insaaf (PTI), formally known as Tehreek Insaaf Pakistan (TIP), TIP however, is a well known term among the bellboys and bellhops, which is perhaps the reason of conversion from TIP to PTI. Anyhow, what lies within the rigging carol is interesting and most of those who have a soft corner for TIP or PTI believe that a movement similar to the PNA movement 1977, is perhaps the only solution to teach PMLN a "lesson". I am assure that most of them know about the PNA movement as shallow as the lead singer of rigging CAROL knows by himself. The purpose of this blog post is to find out what exactly was Pakistan National Alliance (PNA) movement 1977 and what precisely TIP or PTI claims, but first have a recap of the GE2013.

It was long believed by the media analysts prior to the GE'13 that PTI will form the next government of KPK. However, contrary to the tall claims and reflection of what we call Hollow lentil makes more noisePakistan Tehreek Insaaf after the GE'13 emerged as a regional party with some around 3 dozen seats that too mostly from strongholds in Pakhtoon dominated areas only, thus lacking the basis of a national party. More than two third of Pakistan rejected the politics of abuse and mud slinging. In KPK where there is all fine and clear, because Khattak lead PTI is on the driving seat, there are several districts & divisions where they fail to grab a single seat. For example in KPK PTI fails to get the confidence of people of Charsadda, Mansehra, Buttgram, Kohistan DI Khan, Bannu, Laki Marwat, Bunair, Shangla, Chitral, Dir and Malakand. The drama of "Taank Na Janay Waziristan terha" "ٹانک نہ جانے وزیرستان ٹیڑھا " for gaining the sympathies of victims of  US drone attacks was also badly flopped. PTI was not given a pity TIP from FATA people as a token of the modern fashion show in TANK.  Imran Khan lead PTI failed to grab any seat from Kurram, Momand, Bajor, North Waziristan and Orakzai Agency. But since the government is there with Pervaiz Khattak as CM and 3/4 (60 out of 80) of the ruling collation members are enjoying perks as provincial ministers and parliamentary secretaries, every thing is as legitimate and clear as Imran Khan is in the eyes of Haroon Rashid. However, despite  two mammoth gatherings in Lahore, PTI did manged to get a couple of Punjab Assembly and National assembly seats, and here comes the twist. Since, TIP has some huge public gatherings in Lahore therefore, it is a MUST thing to happen that at least 10 /13 seats of NA should fall in the lap of PTI. However, it did not happened and Imran Khan who once declared that he will contest the GE'13 against Mian Nawaz Sharif in NA-120, cowardly decided to stay out of Gawalmandi, thus leaving behind the female contestant Dr. Yasmeen to fight twice elected PM Nawaz Sharif. Similarly, his fellow party member who conducted the rigged party election of PTI, lost his seat against Khawaja Saad Rafiq in NA-125. Remember, it was Hamid Khan who was supposed to file a case against Khawaja Asif, and he FILED but in the lower court, which was rejected by the court stating that the court can not hear a case worth billion rupees. Anyhow, cutting the story short, as an evidence the one and only Dr. Shireen Mehrunnisa Mazari produced a video of rigging in NA-125 in front of whole media. That video however, was an act of lunacy. Hamid Mir showed that video in his program in which SINDH RANGERS were shown inside the poling booth. Nothing was clear, however the mother of all question is "WHAT EXACTLY SINDH RANGERS IS DOING IN NA-125 LAHORE ??" and the father of all question is "How shameful Dr.SHIREEN MAZARI might felt after this blatant lie of rigging in LAHORE?". Try finding the answers and i am shifting to the PNA story in the coming lines.

  1. Pakistan National Alliance (PNA) was an alliance of several parties who participated in GE'77. They alleged ZAB lead PPP for rigging in GE and decided not to be a part of Oath taking ceremony, PTI however took oath after GE'13.  
  2. PNA members decided to launch a country wide protest against the rigging and it was so intense that it brought PPP on the dialog table, PTI also did that near ONE potato Two Potato for a week or two.
  3. As a result of PNA movement the PPP government agreed that re-elections are possible on 40 constituencies (Ref:"Aur line Kat gae" by Kosar Niazi). PMLN however being the winning party has denied any involvement in alleged rigging. 
  4. While PNA was agitating against the rigging the country was under the control of PPP, the chief election commissioner was an appointee of ZAB and so as the interim setup in all the four provinces. Neither happened in GE'13. In Punjab a wave of transfer orders actually shuffled the whole setup of Shahbaz Sharif. 
  5. PNA movement in 1977 was on road because the opposition parties were clear about rigging and they decided not to be a part of democratic setup. In 2013, PTI however is enjoying full protocol in KPK, they have opposition leader in PA and their MNAs are getting full TA and DA for each session. 
  6. In 1977, PNA movement decided to boycott election polling in the daylight without the presence of strong media. In 2013 PTI took part in polling process till the end of the day and waited another 3 hours to compile the results, and then RIGGING word was first introduced to the nation.

My advice, history resists any alteration of facts. Try not to seduce the youth with such events that never existed in the pages of history. Try to focus on the province where you have the majority. The movement of PNA in 1977 was a significant parade of valor, where the people sacrificed for our today. That movement saw historical democratic struggle in Pakistan, neither on bullish Twitter nor on misleading Facebook. PNA was on ground not for hours, but for days and months, while in 2013 PTI in on twitter or near a burger shop. Lets decide to think outside the BUN.


-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
*Editorial Note: If anyone wants to write rebuttal of this blog post. Our blog is there for you. Please write us at                 amidstdemocracy@gmail.com
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

ابہام یا خوف

ابہام یا خوف

تحریر :عامر  نواز خان *

پاکستان کو اس وقت ریاستی چلینجز میں سے ایک سب سے بڑا چیلنج طالبان ہیں۔ اس میں کوئی شک نہیں پاکستان میں تمام طبقات اور ریاستی اداروں کو دہشت گردی کی جنگ میں بھاری جانی و مالی نقصان سے دوچار ہونا پڑا۔پچھلے دنوں حکیم اللہ کی موت (شہادت لکھنا یا اس پر بات کرنا ایک طویل اور لمبی بحث درکار ہے) پر پاکستان میں نظریاتی تفریق واضح طور پر نظر آئی جہاں شعبہ ہائے زندگی سے تعلق رکھنے والے کچھ افراد نے خوشی کا اظہار کیا جبکہ کچھ لوگ اس پر تزبزب کا شکار نظر آئے۔ ایسے موقع پر جب تمام سیاسی اور دینی جماعتوں کو زمہ دارانہ رویہ اختیار کرنا چاہیے تھا مولانا منور حسن اور مولانا فضل الرحمان کے بیانات نے گویا آگ لگا دی۔ میں نہ تو کوئی صحافی ہوں اور نہ ہی عالمی امور پر جامع دسترس رکھتا ہوں مگر ایک عام پاکستانی ہونے کے سامنے کچھ سوال آپ سب دوستوں کے سامنے رکھنا چاہوں گا۔

- اگر طالبان ہمارے اپنے بھائی ہیں تو پچھلے دس سال کے دوران پاکستانی افراد اور مسلح افواج پر حملے کیوں کیے؟
- اگر یہ مفروضہ بھی مان لیا جائے کہ طالبان یہود و ہنود کی سازش کا حصہ ہیں تو انہیں شہید کہنے کی ضرورت کیوں محسوس ہوئی۔
- اگر طالبان ہمارے اپنے لوگ ہیں تو انہوں نے پاکستان کے دستور سے ہمیشہ انکار کیوں کیا؟
- اگر طالبان ملک دشمن قوتوں کے ہاتھوں میں کھیل رہے ہیں تو ان سے مزاکرات کے لیے اتنی منتیں ترلے کس لیے کئے جا رہے ہیں؟
- حالیہ دنوں میجر جنرل نیازی کی شہادت پر تمام سیاسی جماعتوں نے چپ سادھے رکھی جب کہ حکیم اللہ کی موت پر ایک بھونچال آگیا کیوں؟

میں یقین سے نہیں کہہ سکتا کہ حکومت طالبان کے حوالے سے سنجیدہ ہے یا نہیں مگر ایک بات وقت کے ساتھ واضح ہو رہی ہے کہ تمام دینی جماعتیں اور جمہوری جماعتیں طالبان کے حوالے سے یا تو ابہام کا شکار ہیں یا خوف کے باعث ایک واضح موقف اپنانے سے گریز کر رہی ہیں۔ منور حسن نے حکیم اللہ کو شہید کہتے وقت ایک لمحے کا خیال نہیں کیا کہ یہ وہی تحریک طالبان ہے جنہوں نے قاضی حسین احمد کو کافر کہا اور ان پر خودکش حملے کیے؟ کیا مولانا فضل الرحمان اپنی جان کے خوف اور مقامی ہمدردی حاصل کرنے کے لیے طالبان کو گلے لگانے کو مضطرب ہیں؟ یار رکھیں یہ پاکستان کی بقا کی جنگ ہے اور اگر خدانخواستہ پاکستان نہ رہا تو شاید نظریات کی یہ دکانیں کسی اناتھ آشرم کی نظر ہو جائیں۔ یہی وقت ہے جب ریاست کے تمام ادارے بالخصوص پاکستان آرمی اور موجودہ حکومت طالبان کے حوالے سے ایک واضح موقف اپنائیں۔ اگر یہ ہمارے اپنے لوگ ہیں تو انکی زندگی میں واپسی کے لیے ہر ممکن کوششیں کی جائے ورنہ آپ سمجھدار ہیں کہ یہ لوگ کبھی ہتھیار پھینک کر پھول نہیں اٹھایئں گے۔

*پہلے یہاں چھپا 
Wednesday, December 11, 2013

Tariq Malik | An unsung hero or a political gimmick ?

Tariq Malik | An unsung hero or a political gimmick ?

Written by Hadeed Ahmed Sher

The issue of sacking the Chairman NADRA Tariq Malik is circulating in the political circles of Pakistan nowadays. Three days before, at mid night a news waved across the country about the dismissal of Tariq Malik (Later reinstated by the IHC). According to the news reporters he was threatened and pressurized by the Punjab law Minister for a possible voter verification in NA 118, Lahore.  This news has some lessons to learn particularly for the ruling PMLN and generally by all the political parties inside and outside the power corridors.


The very first reaction of the removal of Tariq Malik was amplified because of a government which is lacking an active Information Minister. The social media which always looks for catchy stories, at the drop of the hat, started bashing the PMLN government. The issue of Tariq Malik was the nation wide top trend on twitter, soon after the news erupted and all the PTI supporters joined the bandwagon to "curse" PMLN. The absence of information minister from the scene was similar to the Kargil crisis when after the meeting of PM Nawaz Sharif and US President Bill Clinton, the proprietors of dreams to capture Srinagar opened their mouth guns on Mian Nawaz Sharif. The issue of Tariq Malik, however, was portrayed like he was the one who was about to expose the "rigging" of GE'13, which otherwise were declared justified by neutral international observers. PTI who is constantly alleging its defeat in GE'13 as part of a "big game" cashed the situation and circulated that the chairman NADRA is an upright person and that he was not willing to surrender before the "unconstitutional pressure" of PMLN. They claimed that this person was going to unveil the "massive rigging" in Punjab, where PTI was literally knocked down despite the financial investments of Aleem Khan (EOBI scandal) and the Jahangir Tareen (The Sugar Mafia). Tariq Malik consulted the Islamabad High Court the very next day where he was reinstated by the court in the first hearing (Courts however never liked such rapid actions by the national assembly). As a counter measure the federal government filed a case in Supreme court of Pakistan, thus challenging the decision by the Islamabad High Court. Later on after the debates inside the National Assembly the minister In-charge of Interior Affairs Ch Nisar Ali Khan came to the house and presented the curious case of Tariq Malik. The speech of Ch Nisar had such information that the case of Tariq Malik turned out to be a real can of worms.

According to Ch Nisar Ali Khan, the Chairman NADRA Tariq Malik was appointed Chairman against the NADRA ordinance and was promoted first as a Deputy Chairman NADRA (A designation which do not exist in NADRA hierarchy). Perhaps PPP thought that if a Deputy PM can work unconstitutionally whats so wrong about a deputy Chairman NADRA. Anyhow, the main accusation by Ch Nisar was indeed shocking. He said that despite verbal and 2 written orders NADRA was the only department of Interior Ministry who was reluctant to the financial audit. According to Ch Nisar, he said in a meeting that if Tariq Malik will not provide space for the financial audits he will be sacked. He also revealed that Tariq Malik was appointed chairman NADRA after PM ordered to soften the rules and regulations of NADRA ordinance. Some news reports also inform us that Tariq Malik is a dual national which according to Shireen Mazari is a threat to National Security. Some news also circulated primarily in PMLN circles that Tariq Malik was in cahoots with Malik Riaz and allegedly issued multiple NIC to his  employees  for defeating PMLN in Rawalpindi. 

The first lesson in this story is that never believe on the glitters of our media for false political mileage. The shallow work of our media once again exposed badly in this saga. After proving Tariq Malik the hero standing in between the "dictatorial PMLN" and Pakistan, the very next day media came to know that actually Tariq Malik was a political gimmick and was appointed to this sensitive post just because of his close relationships with the PPP mainstream leadership. Just in one day our so called "investigative" journalist portrayed their shallow depth of work. Therefore everything these "investigative" journalists say, we must take with a pinch of salt.

The second lesson hidden in this issue is the timing. I mean how bizarre and suspicious it looks when late night orders are given to fire a person who is Chairman of a sensitive organization. Back in 1999, it was the same issue of timing when instead of waiting Gen Mushrraf to come back to Pakistan, he was fired midst Colombo-Karachi Flight (That issue was highlighted time and again as a proof of military coup). I am unable to understand that what would have happened if the issue of Tariq Malik was resolved during the daylight. It happened many times that PMLN was right in the case but the mistiming backfired and they were bashed by the media. For the military coup and KARGIL crisis the issue turned in favor of Mian Nawaz Sharif almost after 6 years. Luckily the issue of Tariq Malik is quite known to the people within a weak, although the "naive" information Ministry cut short the broadcasting of speech by an important member of federal cabinet. Hopefully the issue will be amicably resolved in the next few days and will be taken as a lesson that in this Pakistan the late night jackals type actions will never by welcomed by anyone.



Share this

Labels

PTI (12) Democracy (10) Nawaz Sharif (8) PMLN (8) General Elections 2013 (7) Pakistan (7) Imran Khan (6) Irresponsible Media (6) Musharraf (6) PPP (5) Egypt (4) Rigging allegations (4) SCP (4) Taliban (4) media (4) Amir Nawaz Khan (3) Asif Zardari (3) Benazir Bhutto (3) Ch Nisar Ali Khan (3) Judiciary (3) Long March (3) Nausheen Yousuf (3) Police (3) Terrorism (3) Zulfiqar ali Bhutto (3) hadeed sher (3) Army Rule (2) Attack on state institutes (2) Azadi March (2) Baiber Saladin (2) Bomb (2) Contempt of court (2) Dictatorship (2) Establishment (2) Hamid Khan (2) Iftikhar Muhammad Ch. (2) Institutions (2) Investigation procedures (2) Javed Hashmi (2) KPK government (2) Kargil (2) Khawaja Saad Rafiq (2) Martial Law (2) NRO (2) National Assembly (2) Social media (2) TTP (2) Turkey (2) Urdu blog (2) 1977 Elections (1) Afzaal Farooqui (1) Akbar Bugti (1) Altaf Hussain (1) Article 6 (1) Ayesha Rehman (1) Ayub Khan (1) BJP (1) Bangladesh (1) Blue Area incident (1) By Elections (1) By Elections 2013 (1) CNN (1) Cantonment board elections 2015 (1) Change (1) CoAS (1) Columns (1) Constitution (1) Daily Express (1) Democractic practices (1) Drama (1) Drone attacks (1) ECP (1) Education Emergency (1) Elections (1) Enlighten moderation (1) Extremism (1) Federal Cabinet 2013 (1) Gen Kiani (1) General Raheel Shareef (1) Hamid Mir (1) Ideology (1) JI jirga (1) Jahangir Tareen (1) Jason Miks (1) Kisan Package (1) Liaqat Ali Khan (1) Liberation of thoughts (1) Mamnoon Hussain (1) Military Establishment (1) NA 154 (1) NADRA (1) NDMA (1) Nanga Parbat Massacre (1) Okara (1) Pak Army (1) Pakistan National Alliance (1) Pakistan Railways (1) Parliament (1) Politics (1) Presendential Elections (1) Presidential Elections 2013 (1) Prisoners (1) Protests (1) Punjab (1) Raza Rabbani (1) Religion (1) Resignations of PTI (1) Sardar Ayyaz Sadiq (1) Saulat Mirza (1) Secularism (1) Senate (1) South Punjab (1) Suo Moto actions (1) Tahir Al Qadri (1) Tariq Malik (1) Tax evaders (1) Tourism (1) US Elections (1) WAPDA (1) White Paper (1) Writ of the state (1) Zahida Hina (1) Zia ul Haq (1) federation (1) freedom of press (1) twitter (1)
Powered by Blogger.

Followers

Disclaimer

- Copyright © Amidst Democracy -Metrominimalist- Powered by Blogger - Designed by Johanes Djogan -